catch-22
MP Sir Andrew Mitchell has criticized plans to improve transparency over company ownership in Guernsey and Jersey, saying they 'do not go nearly far enough'.
The comments come after the governments of Guernsey and Jersey set out plans to allow approved applicants access to information about who owns or controls companies when investigating suspected financial crime.
MP Sir Andrew Mitchell said limits on access to the information could mean that national security threats may remain entirely invisible to investigators.
The new proposals would allow journalists, academics and other applicants with a legitimate interest to apply for access.
Sir Andrew said investigators could face a 'catch-22' because they may need access to the register to prove wrongdoing in the first place.
He also said he understood applicants would have to show they had been unable to find the information elsewhere, arguing: 'This entirely defeats the object of a register. '
Jersey's consultation response says applicants would be expected to show that all reasonable alternative sources have been exhausted before access was granted.
Guernsey's published response does not explicitly set out the same requirement.
He said: 'Access should be open to those from other jurisdictions, for example those in the global south from whom much of the world's dirty money was stolen in the first place. '
Sir Andrew also questioned whether users would have to pay to access the information, saying: 'This information should be free at the point of access.
He said the proposals should eventually lead to fully public registers.
A Government of Jersey spokesperson said the concerns raised by him do not accurately reflect what is in Jersey's consultation response paper.
They said the policy was intended to help Jersey meet its international commitments while maintaining 'a fair, proportionate, and effective transparency framework. '
Deputy Andrew Niles, from Guernsey's Policy & Resources Committee, rejected Sir Andrew's criticism and pointed to a positive 2025 assessment of the island's efforts to tackle financial crime, external.
He said: 'Guernsey does not accept the suggestion that our proposals fall short of the commitments we've made on beneficial ownership transparency or that the island does not meet international standards on beneficial ownership transparency. '
Follow BBC Guernsey on X, external, Facebook, external and Instagram, external. Send your story ideas to channel. islands@bbc. co. uk, external.
Beneficial ownership proposals by the end of year
Plan to name company owners to curb
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0